Skip to main content

Future Leader

Communication

How to Give Feedback to a Peer Without Making It Awkward

Feedback between peers is not about authority. It is about caring enough to say the useful thing out loud.

Imagine you share a project with a colleague who is great to work with, except for one thing. Their part always arrives late, usually the night before it is due, and you end up rushing your own work to fit around it.

You have mentioned it as a joke once or twice. They laughed. Nothing changed. Now you are quietly frustrated, and the frustration is starting to show in how you talk to them.

This is the moment most people avoid. It is also one of the most valuable leadership skills you can build before you ever manage anyone.

Why peer feedback feels so hard

When you give feedback to someone who reports to you, the role gives you permission. With a peer, there is no permission slip. You worry they will think you are overstepping, that it will damage the relationship, or that they will throw something back at you.

So people do one of two things. They hint, which rarely works, or they wait until they are annoyed enough to blurt it out badly. Neither helps the other person improve.

A five-step approach that keeps it calm

1. Ask first

Asking permission changes the whole tone. It turns feedback from an attack into an offer.

“Have you got five minutes? There’s something small about how we hand work over that I think could make things easier for both of us.”

2. Describe what happened, not what they are

Stick to something a camera could record. “Your section arrived at 11pm the last three times” is a fact. “You’re always disorganised” is a judgement, and judgements start arguments.

3. Explain the impact

People change when they understand the effect of what they do. Keep it about the work, not your feelings alone.

“When it comes in late, I don’t have time to check how our parts fit together, so the final version ends up rougher than either of us wants.”

4. Ask for their side

This is the step most people skip. There may be a reason you cannot see: unclear instructions, another deadline, a part that is harder than it looks. Ask, then actually listen.

“Is something making that part harder to finish earlier?”

5. Agree one small next step

End with something specific you both agree on, not a vague promise to “do better.” For example: share a rough draft two days before the deadline, even if it is messy.

Three habits that make it easier

  • Give positive feedback just as specifically. If you only speak up when something is wrong, every conversation feels like a warning. Notice what works and say so.
  • Do it privately and soon. Feedback in front of others feels like a public correction. Feedback weeks later feels like you have been keeping score.
  • Skip the compliment sandwich. Wrapping criticism between two compliments makes people distrust your praise. Be kind and direct instead.

What if it goes badly?

Sometimes the other person gets defensive. That is normal. Do not argue the details. Acknowledge it and give them space: “I can tell that landed badly. I’m not trying to criticise you, I just want this project to go well for both of us.” Most people come back to it calmly a day later.

Try this week

Pick one small thing a peer does well and tell them specifically what it was and why it helped. Practising positive feedback makes the harder conversations feel much more natural.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *